Myer’s proposed merger with Premier’s Apparel Brands is a convenient solution for two ex-growth businesses. For Premier, the inferred multiple is only 4.1x EV/EBIT, which is low. Premier shareholders could receive 8.2 Myer shares, with upside through an estimated $55 million in synergies. The majority of the synergies will come from adding Premier to Myer stores in concession space and improved terms on sourcing product. The merger raises the prospect that a further Strategic Review for Premier is unlikely to crystallise much value.

Metcash reported FY24 EBIT down 1% and, adjusted for acquisitions, it was a similar result in both the first and second-half. The company is actively managing costs to offset weak sales trends and this thematic is likely to be a feature again in FY25e. Metcash’s performance relative to market growth remains impressive and is the primary reason for our positive stance on the stock.

City Chic’s exit of Avenue and capital raising conclude an incredibly painful experience of global ambition and then retreat. The City Chic brand has a strong following in Australia but has been impacted by excess inventory. The company is addressing its cost base but more savings will be needed to restore profitability. Moreover, store openings seem unlikely at this stage given the poor sales productivity.

Nick Scali is a furniture retailer that has exhibited consistent growth over the long term. We see the store network growing to 153 over the next four years to FY27e, a compound annual growth rate of 9%. New stores will come in both existing markets and the newly entered UK market. The opportunistic, low-cost entry into the UK sets a base from which to expand the Nick Scali brand into the UK.

Treasury Wines update on its Penfolds division highlights the confidence the company has in the long-term global demand for its luxury wines. The company has lifted key product prices by 6% and will have more luxury wines to sell by FY26e under Penfolds Bin & Icon labels. The biggest swing factor for long-term earnings growth in this business will be the momentum in the global luxury wine market.

Bapcor has disclosed a conditional indicative offer from Bain Capital at $5.40 per share, a 23% premium to the 1-month VWAP. We expect the Board will view the offer as opportunistic and may not even allow due diligence at the prevailing offer price. Bapcor’s EBITDA margins are well below US peers and its own aspirations under the Better Than Before program. While Bapcor’s realisation of cost savings has clearly been delayed, the company still believes in the long-term potential for better profit margins. We place a 25% probability of a takeover proceeding for Bapcor. A successful takeover offer will require a price over $6.00 per share in our view and Board support.

Treasury’s site trip and our meetings in Paso Robles have highlighted the advantage Treasury has in this fast growing wine region. Treasury’s existing facilities combined with extra luxury wine supply at DAOU provides an underpinning for sales and EBITS growth in the Americas. The distinct advantage at Paso is its far lower cost of production. We expect the company to deliver on synergies and double-digit revenue growth from its luxury portfolio and investor confidence in the DAOU acquisition will grow following the trip.

Australia’s national accounts reveals that income growth remains strong and consumers are spending more money outside of retail. For the March 2024 quarter, household income rose 5.1% and total consumer spending was up 5.9%, whereas retail spending only rose 2.5%. Households are saving very little of their income, a reflection of stored up savings from the past four years, but also a reminder that consumers will be more value conscious. We expect similar trends to constrain a retail recovery in FY25e as households allocate spending elsewhere and lower retail price inflation dampens overall revenue.

Lovisa has extended its CEO contract for Victor Herrero to May 2025. John Cheston will be appointed as successor to take Lovisa at the start of FY26e. Mr Cheston comes from Premier Investments as Managing Director of Smiggle, overseeing its expansion into foreign markets over the last decade. With the change to CEO, we lower our Lovisa store rollout forecast in FY25 by 50 stores largely effecting the probability of an accelerated China rollout.

Australian retail sales rose 1.2% in April 2024. To adjust for the noise of the timing of Easter we also look at the combined March-April results which shows sales growth of only 1.3%. Department stores and fashion have had the most notable slowdown over the Easter trading period. Supermarket sales are also soft considering data suggests higher inflation in March-April. We forecast subdued retail sales growth trends to continue to June 2024, with a mild pick up for the back-half of calendar 2024.