Premier Investments reported 1H26 Retail EBIT (pre AASB-16 and excluding significant items) of $119 million, down 7.8%. Total sales were flat with gross margin of 66.9%, which fell 92bp. With Peter Alexander sales per store slowing and the UK in trial phase, a Smiggle turnaround will drive the earnings growth.

Nick Scali delivered 1H26 EBIT of $68.5 million, up 25%. NPAT of $41 million was ahead of both guidance and Visible Alpha consensus. The group gross margin increase of 318bp, surprised to the upside and resulted in 65.4% for the half. Nick Scali’s ANZ trading update for January like-for-like written sales orders at 3.1% highlighted a deterioration in momentum. We have lowered our sales forecasts but lifted gross margin expectations.

Premier Investments’ AGM trading update gave EBIT guidance for 1H26e of $120 million on a pre AASB-16 basis exclusive of significant items (UK losses for Peter Alexander). Visible Alpha consensus estimates appeared muddied by various factors causing uncertainty around earnings changes. Limited AGM detail provided suggests Peter Alexander continues to perform but sales and gross margins at Smiggle have continued to deteriorate.

Nick Scali’s AGM guidance was a miss to Visible Alpha consensus for 1H26e. However, the trading update showed strong sales momentum in ANZ and a clear path to breakeven in the UK. The ANZ guidance implies either flat gross margins or elevated costs. Sales momentum will need to continue in a highly promotional environment to offset cost growth. The UK is tracking well to reach breakeven and could exit 2H26e with a small profit. The promotional environment in ANZ presents a risk to gross margins.

Premier Investments reported FY25 Retail EBIT of $183 million, down 24%. FY25 sales performance was divergent for Peter Alexander and Smiggle with the same trend continuing it is trading update. We downgrade EPS by 3.4% and 4.5% in FY26e and FY27e given store closures and continued sales declines at Smiggle. We have also lowered our gross margin given commentary about a competitive market. Cost discipline remains a theme at Premier. Earnings growth will be delivered in FY26e but beyond that success will be determined by a recovery at Smiggle and the success of the Peter Alexander expansion to the UK.

Nick Scali delivered EBIT of $106 million, down 18%. Gross margins in ANZ were down 100bp but remain elevated on history at 65%. The UK losses at $9.6 million exceeded expectations, with losses guided to continue. Our EPS revisions are a downgrade of 1.6% to FY26e but upgrades of 2.5% and 1.5% to FY27e and FY28e. A large sales uplift is required to break even in the UK, with current conditions supportive domestically. Nick Scali will have to deliver on the UK and on growth in the domestic market.

Nick Scali delivered a better than expected earnings result and the gross margin recovery since the AGM guidance was a standout. We see 2H gross margin holding flat on last year for ANZ, with group gross margins at 62.3% for FY25e. Initial signs of UK improvement and hints of greenfield expansion has seen confidence grow in the UK rollout. There is, however, now little room for error in execution.

Nick Scali’s AGM trading update revealed improving written sales order trends but highlighted the disconnect to recorded sales with 1H25e revenue for ANZ guided down 3%. Sea freight rate exposure has dented gross margins in the near term pushing 1H25e ANZ EBIT margins down to FY19 levels. The UK is set to reach profitability in 2H26e and saw gross margin improvement as new product is introduced to stores.

Premier Investments reported FY24 Retail EBIT down 9% to $326 million. Gross margins finished higher with a second-half increase of 94bp. Cost management during FY24 helped offset the operational leverage of lower sales. The delayed strategic review allows the board to focus on the Myer merger proposal. 

Nick Scali reported an EBIT result of $130 million for FY24, down 16%. Gross margin of 65.5% for the group and 66.0% the Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) division was a standout and record. For FY25e we expect to see modest store openings, an improvement in per store sales growth momentum from ANZ and moderate cost growth. A catalyst to the upside would be a lower sea freight rate environment and progress in the UK.