Treasury Wines has provided an update on FY25e earnings and noted that its US distributor in California will exit the state. The loss of RNDC will be a short-term risk given the short-term timeframe of September 2025. We have a cautious outlook on the US business with EBITS ex DAOU down 24% in FY26e.

Treasury Wine’s share price suggests there is downside risks to consensus earnings. We agree and the opportunity for incoming CEO Sam Fischer will be a reset of expectations because the fundamentals of the business are solid. Treasury has repositioned its portfolio towards luxury wines where Chinese and global demand are both strong.

Wesfarmers reported 1H25 EBIT growth of 5%. It was a solid sales and margin result in Kmart and WesCEF. Bunnings showed better sales trends, although underlying margins dropped slightly. The swing factor for Wesfarmers earnings growth over the next few years remains lithium and the path to profitability is most likely another 18 months away. Investors will need patience as well as optimism that lithium prices can rise from current depressed levels.

City Chic’s trading update for 1H25e shows an improvement in sales compared with six months ago, but ongoing challenges in the US and operating losses. We expect better profit margins in 2H25e given cost savings and more full-priced sales. However, we are more cautious on the sales outlook. Fundamentally, City Chic has stabilised its business, but the prospect for decent profit margins is still some way off. 

Harvey Norman reported FY24 EBITDA down 11% with a drop in Franchising and New Zealand earnings and increase in its property earnings. The company has lost market share in both Australia and New Zealand over the past five years and its EBITDA margin recovery is yet to emerge. We expect New Zealand to remain a headwind in FY25e but Australian earnings should rise slightly. The quality of the FY24 result was low with reduced lease amortisation supporting earnings.

City Chic reported an FY24 pre-AASB 16 EBITDA loss of $19 million, an $8 million smaller loss than in FY23. This was a beat to the guidance of -$22 million provided at the time of the capital raising in June 2024. City Chic’s trading update showed positive comparable sales up 9.9% and further, provided revenue guidance of $142 to $160 million for FY25e.

Lovisa reported FY24 EBIT of $128 million, up 21%. Sales of $697 million, up 17.3% were a 2% miss to Visible Alpha consensus. The comparable sales trading update at 2.0%, while an improvement on 2H24 was lower than consensus expectation. Sales on a per store basis in A$ were lower across all segments. The gross margin performance was a highlight, delivering 81.2% in 2H24 and 80.9% for the full year, up 108bp. Elevated costs, especially wages and rents, suggest there is little operating leverage being realised so far.

Wesfarmers reported modest EBIT growth of 3% in FY24 with low growth for Bunnings, a decline in WesCEF and strong rise in Kmart EBIT the notable factors. Bunnings earnings growth is likely to remain low over the next two years given limited store openings and a challenging demand backdrop. We think Kmart’s margins are near a peak, particularly given price competition with rivals is heating up. WesCEF and lithium become the key driver of Wesfarmers earnings from here and it will take up to three years to see meaningful earnings.

Woolworths reported FY24 EBIT of $3,223 million, up 3% on a reported basis, or 1.1% adjusted for the extra week. Second-half EBIT fell by 1.3%. While Australian Food EBIT was decent, New Zealand Food and Big W had very weak results. Online sales are accelerating for Woolworths, but the overall benefit to earnings seems limited given supermarket store profits declined in 2H24. Woolworths also provided guidance on capex at $2.0-$2.2 billion for FY25e.

Coles reported underlying EBIT up 5.7% for FY24 on a 52-week basis. EBIT growth in Supermarkets was much stronger in the second-half but Liquor earnings fell significantly. Coles had a step-down in sales trends in 2H24 and these are likely to continue. The gross margin gains from lower stock loss in FY25e should underpin a flat EPS year with better EPS growth in FY26e as the benefits of the Witron and Ocado capex projects comes to fruition.