Woolworths is having a challenging time in its core supermarket business. The recent distribution centre strike will impact sales and earnings in 2Q25e, but should dissipate. More fundamentally, the company’s price investment is unlikely to deliver a decent return and online sales are margin dilutive. Across the industry, the drop in supermarket inflation gives us cause for concern about the industry’s sales and margin outlook over the next two years. While a short-term winner from the strikes, broader industry sales weakness will make it hard for Coles to deliver decent sales growth in 2025.

Coles reported underlying EBIT up 5.7% for FY24 on a 52-week basis. EBIT growth in Supermarkets was much stronger in the second-half but Liquor earnings fell significantly. Coles had a step-down in sales trends in 2H24 and these are likely to continue. The gross margin gains from lower stock loss in FY25e should underpin a flat EPS year with better EPS growth in FY26e as the benefits of the Witron and Ocado capex projects comes to fruition.

Woolworths 1H24 EBIT growth of 3% revealed a stark contrast amongst its divisions, with Australian Food EBIT up 10%, but NZ earnings down 41% and Big W down 60%. The challenge for the company is that its Australian Food sales are slowing rapidly. We also expect the outsized contribution from eCommerce and Digital & Data to moderate. The concern is lower food inflation crimping Food segment margins and a lower profit margin for Big W. With a change of CEO and weaker food inflation outlook, we expect the earnings outlook on the company to be moderated.