We are approaching the most important time of year for retailers where a successful festive season can make or break the year. For 2023, retailers are planning bigger and earlier events in November. Black Friday sales are likely to pull forward spending yet again. We expect the most noticeable boost to sales in electronics and recreational goods where supply has improved. While there is upside risk to consensus sales for 1H24e, the challenge will be profit margins. We are more cautious on margins and see a downside skew to risks given earlier discounting by retailers.